top of page

Treating The Whole You

SARA JANE HEALTH & NUTRITION BLOG

Search

The 5 Worst Diets You Should Think Twice About


When it comes to dieting, not all plans are created equal. Some popular programs seem promising but can lead to poor health outcomes and fail to provide sustainable results. Here’s a closer look at these diets and why they might not be the best choice for your long-term health.


1. The Bad Version of the Atkins Diet: Atkins was once celebrated for its emphasis on low-carb eating. However, its modern-day UK offerings—like bars and shakes—are heavily processed. These products often include:

  • Soy protein isolates: A heavily processed ingredient that can disrupt hormone balance.

  • Sucralose: An artificial sweetener that harms the gut health by disrupting beneficial bacteria.

  • Canola oil: A refined seed oil linked to inflammation.


The reliance on such processed ingredients can stall weight loss, lead to cravings, and negatively impact energy levels. While initially effective for weight loss, the lack of nutrient density makes this diet hard to sustain and can set the stage for weight regain.


2. Slimming World: Slimming World is loved for its flexibility, but its branded products like Hi-Fi bars and low-syn snacks often rely on:


  • Sugar substitutes: These trigger cravings and negatively affects metabolism.

  • Refined ingredients: While low-calorie, these lack the fibre and nutrients your body needs for genuine satiety and health.


Relying on these products can leave dieters feeling deprived and prone to yo-yo dieting, as they don’t encourage a real shift toward whole-food eating habits.


3. Weight Watchers (WW): WW is a household name in the UK, but its prepackaged meals like Smart Ones and WW-branded snacks are riddled with:


  • Maltodextrin: A processed carbohydrate that spikes blood sugar levels even more than table sugar.

  • Soybean oil: Often associated with increased inflammation.

  • Wheat flour and gluten: Common allergens that irritate the gut.


The focus on calorie counting rather than nutrient quality means participants might lose weight initially but fail to improve their overall health. Long-term use of such products often leads to nutritional deficiencies and fatigue.


4. SlimFast: SlimFast markets convenience through shakes and bars, but its products often rely on:


  • Maltodextrin and sugar: These drive blood sugar spikes, leading to energy crashes and cravings.

  • Artificial flavours: These provide no nutritional value and can overstimulate taste buds, making whole foods seem bland.


This quick-fix approach can leave the body deprived of essential nutrients like healthy fats and fibre, which are critical for hormonal balance and sustained energy.


5. Herbalife: Herbalife shakes and supplements are heavily processed and filled with:


  • Artificial sweeteners: Potentially harmful to gut microbiome diversity.

  • Synthetic vitamins: These don’t provide the same benefits as nutrients derived from whole foods.


While marketed as “nutritional,” these products lack the balance of macronutrients and micronutrients needed for long-term health, often leaving dieters dependent on the brand rather than developing sustainable habits.


Extreme calorie restriction can slow metabolism, weaken the immune system, and lead to muscle loss, making it unsustainable and unhealthy in the long run.


Why These Diets Fail Long-Term


These diets focus on quick weight loss through calorie restriction and processed meal replacements, which often have the following consequences:


  1. Metabolism Damage: Extreme calorie deficits can slow your metabolic rate, making it harder to maintain weight loss.

  2. Gut Health Issues: Artificial sweeteners and processed ingredients harm the microbiome, affecting digestion and overall health.

  3. Nutritional Deficiencies: These diets lack the diverse nutrients found in whole foods, leaving you fatigued and at risk of health issues.

  4. Addictive Ingredients: Sugar, artificial flavours, and refined starches can increase cravings and make it hard to break unhealthy eating habits.

  5. Hormonal Disruption: Processed seed oils and soy derivatives interfere with hormones, leading to mood swings and energy imbalances.


A Better Way Forward


Ready to take control of your health and make lasting changes? Let’s work together to create a plan tailored to your unique needs and goals. Whether you’re looking to improve your energy, balance your hormones, or simply feel your best, I’m here to support you every step of the way. Schedule a free discovery call to start your journey toward a healthier, happier you!

Get In Touch

Location

Matlock Bath, Derbyshire

Email

sara@sarajanehealthandnutrition.co.uk

Social Media

  • Join Me On Instagram
  • Join Me On Linked In
  • Join Me on Facebook
  • TikTok

© 2024 by Sara Jane Health & Nutrition.

All Rights Reserved.

Qualifications

Certified Naturopathic Nutritionist at the renowned College of Naturopathic Medicine.

Certified by ITEC and VCTC in  Complementary Therapy

Certified Yoga Teacher with Yoga Alliance 

REPs Certified

Registered Yoga Teacher
CNM Logo
ANP Logo
VTCT Logo
iTEC Logo

Subscribe!

Join my monthly newsletter full of inspiring hints, hacks, tips and much more!

Thank You for Subscribing!

Book a free 15 minute discovery call

bottom of page